Lisa L. Smith Blog
Post #2: “The Pleasure Principal” Nancie Atwell
September
After reading this article, I was convinced that reading for
pleasure must be promoted at the earliest age possible. There are many activities that we do in the
name of reading, but actual reading is not always one of those activities. As a parent of a dyslexic child, I know the
frustration that was caused by years of spelling tests, word searches, and
worksheets. My child became a reader
under a teacher that taught her how to love to read. This teacher used the ideas presented in the
article. She helped my child enjoy
reading, realize she didn’t have to be a perfect reader, encouraged her to take
risks, and helped her learn to choose books she enjoyed. This one year with a teacher that valued
reading for pleasure changed the course of my child’s future.
The article promotes a practice called reading
workshop. During reading workshop, the
teacher may have a short mini lesson, but then the children are engaged in
reading. The article speaks about the
students being transported into a reading zone.
I totally understand this concept, because as an avid reader myself, I
often find myself in the reading zone, unable to put down a good book even
though it is 1:00 in the morning. We
want children to become so engaged in a text that they don’t want to put it
down either.
This article also contains a “Bill of Rights” for
readers. It was very eye-opening to read
these rights. They do seem like simple
rights, but I would venture to say that many children do not know its okay to “give
up” on a book because they are not interested in it. They may see this as a failure, but if we
instruct them through reading workshop that it is actually a good practice to
stop reading a book you do not enjoy and find another book. The “rights” hit home hard with me because as
a parent of a dyslexic child that struggled with school and hated going until the
4th grade, I know that these rights are important. I know that allowing a child to read an “easy”
book helps them to feel successful and hopefully gain the confidence to try
something a little harder. We must help
students through this reading workshop model to become readers that are
engaged, confident, and most of all readers that enjoy reading for the pure
pleasure of reading.
I agree with what you took from the article "The Pleasure Principle". It is really important for children to actually enjoy what they are reading. I remember going through school and dreading having to read some of those "required texts" because they weren't always the types of books that I liked to read. I instead, found pleasure in reading books that I had chosen for myself. When students are actually able to make their own choice about what they read, they will enjoy it more, thus learn more. I also agree with you about teaching kids that it is okay to stop reading a book that they don't enjoy. If they're not enjoying it, then they probably aren't even really reading it anyway. If they know that it is okay to stop reading that book and choose one they they will enjoy, they will see reading as a much more inviting task and perhaps something that they will enjoy for leisure.
ReplyDeleteYour personal connection with your own child's experience as a reader strongly influences your own beliefs as a teacher of reading. And you raise a good point--isn't it interesting that what we may or may not have intentionally taught students were "failures" in reading are actually parts of their bill of rights as readers?? What does this mean for your classroom practice?
ReplyDelete